← All comparisons

American Staffordshire Terrier vs Australian Shepherd

Two dog breeds, side by side. Same data, no favourites.

American Staffordshire TerrierAustralian Shepherd
Lifespan10-15 years12-15 years
SizeMediumMedium
Weight40-70 lb40-65 lb
EnergyHighVery high
GroomingLowModerate
SheddingModerateHigh
With kidsWith supervisionWith supervision

What actually separates them

The honest downside of each

American Staffordshire Terrier

This breed carries some of the most restrictive breed-specific legislation of any dog worldwide — outright bans or ownership conditions exist in multiple countries and in various US cities and counties — and many landlords and home-insurance policies exclude the breed by name regardless of an individual dog's temperament or training.

Australian Shepherd

Aussies were bred to work livestock all day and genuinely need a job — hours of real exercise and mental work, every day, for their whole life — and a meaningful share of the breed carries a gene (MDR1) that makes standard doses of common parasite-prevention and anesthesia drugs potentially toxic, which is worth knowing before any vet visit.

Read the full pages

American Staffordshire Terrier  ·  Australian Shepherd
Health problems, origin and what living with each is actually like.